American Idol - Who Get's The Boot - Part 9

[Professor Jam]

Looks like George Huff was the last great hope for the males in this contest, with women raining in control tonights song topic is no track....

WHO GETS THE BOOT THIS WEEK!

The finalists this week are:

Diana DeGarmo
Age:16
Snellville, GA

Fantasia Barrino
Age:19
High Point, NC

Jasmine Trias
Age:17
Mililani, HI
Status: Finalist

LaToya London
Age:25
Oakland, CA
------------------------------------------------

[Professor Jam]

I vote for Jasmine Trias to go this week....

[DJMC]

Agreed...Jasmine is a goner........she's a hottie nevertheless......

[Glen Millar]

Jasmine Trias

Her voice broke at least 5 times I counted. She may be a hottie as DJMC says, but when the voice breaks, that kills the song

My prediction....it is down to La Toya and Diana. Fantasia always picks songs just beyond her range and that will be her downfall.

La Toya and Diana have the 2 best voices of the final 5 and both have the potential to be stars. Especially Diana as her voice will only get better with maturity.

We will see in 2 weeks.

[Professor Jam]

Did you guys notice the make overs that started this week...

[Glen Millar]

TRAVESTY!!!!!

Honestly and totally this is a total travesty. There should be NO WAY that Jasmine was "safe" and to boot La Toya is Wrong, wrong wrong.

This has just guaranteed Diana as winner.

[djdonny]

Jam,

Is it possible to make a separate forum topic for Idol? I know I'm in the minority, but I have absolutely no interest in the show, so I keep having to mark all these posts as "read." Since there are so many posts about Idol, ...

Thanks,

Donny

[Professor Jam]

Djdonny
The show is over in two weeks so a dedicated form would be needed but might be considered next season.

Glen, I totally agree.. I knew last night when she looked into the camera and started to cry she would get the sympathy vote. What’s weird is my wife wanted La Toya to go and agreed Jasmine performance did not hold up.
I can see a new judging platform established for next season on the show. I have judged many beauty pageants over the years and I remember once being caught in the middle of a similar situation… The show promoter rigged the contest, the reason we know is the three judges compared scores and we all picked the same winner… The lesson I learned after this was any competition I was involved ever to be involved with the judge sheets and scores must be made public.
I could see that show giving 50% of the score to phone in votes, 10% to a guest judging celebrity artist and the remaining 40% to the three critics.


voted out this week:

LaToya London
Age:25
Oakland, CA

[DJMC]

Maybe Elton John was right after all........the voters are RACIST!

and Fantasia got the next lowest vote total!

(But, I've said before Fantasia is too ethnic-looking to win this competition. People can't look past her appearance and there are others who think she is copying Macy Gray)