American Idol - Who Get's The Boot - Part 4

[Professor Jam]

The List Grows Shorter..... Week four and it's getting tought and a continue challenge between us and the grneral public.....

The finalist this week are:

Camile Velasco
Age:18
Haiku, Maui

Diana DeGarmo
Age:16
Snellville, GA

Fantasia Barrino
Age:19
High Point, NC

George Huff
Age:22
New Orleans, LA

Jasmine Trias
Age:17
Mililani, HI
Status: Finalist

Jennifer Hudson
Age:22
Chicago, IL

John Stevens
Age:16
East Amherst, NY

Jon Peter Lewis
Age:24
Rexburg, ID

LaToya London
Age:25
Oakland, CA
------------------------------------------------

[djhath]

John Stevens was the absolute worst this week. I haven't seen him sing anything good except for Crooner music.

JPL was way off, including attempting to add his dancing to a slower tune again.

Camile sounded like she was crying the whole song, like she was when she was standing next to Elton John.

One of these three absolutely has to go (though I'd rather it be one of the first two).

[Professor Jam]

John I could post a reply in the same manner however, you are only allowed one vote or selection - It makes us more spicific in a choice to see how we do...

I select;

John Stevens
Age:16
East Amherst, NY

[diskjokk]

Hello,

I'm Mario McQuay, and I approve this message:

My guess is that Jon Stevens gets the boot.

That's my vote and i'm sticking to it.

[DJMC]

John Stephens is MY choice to get the axe....

but I've been wrong about this for the past 3 weeks in a row!!!

(he must be getting the "gender preference impaired" vote..LOL)

[SOHO]

I think this week it will be Camile that goes.

There are a few others that may be equally deserving but Camile just has the stage presence of a cowering, trembling beaten dog. Her vocals always seem shaky at best. It seems as though she just needs some formal training. She has a nice voice but appears to have no control of its dynamics. She has no 'punch' during powerful phrases and too loud during subtle phrases. I keep waiting for her to burst into tears mid-song all of the time.

[Professor Jam]

WOW...

I don't uderstand the bottom three - I'm thinking a bunch of 12 year olds have a crush on the boys or allot of individuals vote to throw the contest... I do aree with one individual in the bottom and tonight... She is gone!


Camile Velasco
Age:18
Haiku, Maui
Status: Finalist

NEXT WEEK NOTE: I'm speaking at DJ Idea Sharing 7 and will be gone - But I will post the vote out thread on Sunday or Monday...

P.S.S. What was Jasmin doing as the bottom two!

Jam-

They seem to have a "surprise" person every week. Wouldn't be surprised to see George and Fantasia there in the next few weeks.

The two white boys need to be put out of their misery.

I wish they would do a negative vote week. That is what people REALLY want to do- vote someone off. :eplaugh

[DJMC]

Interesting view of Am-Idol in this article:

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4649112/